Organisation Change and Performance of Commercial Banks in Delta and River State Nigeria
CHAPTER ONE
Objective of the Study
- To examine the effect of organizational change on the operational efficiency of commercial banks in Delta and Rivers States.
- To assess how digital transformation influences customer satisfaction in commercial banks within these states.
- To analyze the impact of restructuring on the financial performance of commercial banks in Delta and Rivers States.
- To evaluate the role of employee adaptability in the success of organizational change within the banking sector.
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
Introduction
Chapter Two aims to provide a comprehensive review of existing literature relevant to the study of organizational change in the Nigerian banking sector. The chapter focuses on key themes, including a conceptual review of organizational change, change management, and digital transformation in banks. It also examines relevant theoretical frameworks that explain organizational behavior during change processes. Empirical studies on change initiatives and their impact on performance are discussed, followed by an identification of research gaps. This literature review is crucial for establishing a solid foundation for the study, identifying existing knowledge gaps, and guiding the research design and methodology.
Conceptual Review
Organizational Change
Organizational change refers to the process by which organizations modify their structure, strategies, processes, or culture to adapt to internal or external factors. It involves alterations that can range from small, incremental adjustments to significant transformations. This process is crucial for ensuring that organizations remain competitive, efficient, and aligned with their goals. For businesses, especially in the banking sector, change is imperative for responding to evolving market demands, technological advancements, and regulatory pressures. Organizations that fail to adapt may face stagnation or decline in performance, making organizational change a vital component for long-term success (Hassan, 2023).
The importance of organizational change lies in its ability to help businesses stay competitive and responsive to their environment. In the fast-paced world of business, change allows organizations to refine their processes, improve efficiency, and foster innovation. For instance, adopting new technologies can improve productivity, customer service, and data management in the banking sector. Additionally, organizational change can enhance employee engagement and satisfaction by introducing new leadership practices or addressing issues in the corporate culture. As organizations continuously strive to meet customer expectations and maximize their operational efficiency, effective change management becomes a key determinant of success (Bausch, 2022).
There are different types of organizational change, and understanding these classifications helps in determining the best approach to implementation. Planned change refers to intentional, systematic efforts to bring about specific transformations within the organization. These changes are often carefully designed, structured, and managed to achieve desired outcomes. For instance, banks might plan digital transformations to improve service delivery and internal processes. On the other hand, unplanned change occurs due to unforeseen circumstances, such as economic shocks or regulatory changes. Unplanned changes are often reactive, and organizations may struggle to manage them effectively (Green, 2023).
CHAPTER THREE
METHODOLOGY
Research Design
Research design refers to the overall plan or blueprint for conducting a study, outlining how the research will be structured and organized to answer the research questions (Saunders, Lewis, & Thornhill, 2019). For this study, a quantitative research design was adopted, which involves collecting numerical data to quantify variables and analyze relationships between them. A quantitative approach is well-suited for this research as it allows for systematic collection, analysis, and interpretation of data, thus offering an objective and statistical evaluation of the phenomenon under investigation (Bell, 2022). The adoption of a quantitative survey research design was justified because it enables the researcher to collect data from a larger sample, thus providing a comprehensive view of the variables. Specifically, a survey approach allows for structured data collection, facilitating easy comparison and statistical analysis (Creswell & Creswell, 2018). By utilizing a questionnaire, the study was able to gather standardized responses, which ensured consistency and comparability of data across all respondents.
The survey method is particularly beneficial for studies seeking to gather a large amount of data in a short period, as it is cost-effective, efficient, and allows for the generalization of findings to a larger population (Tashakkori & Teddlie, 2017). This design is appropriate for understanding the relationship between organizational change and its impact on employee performance, as it enables the examination of a range of variables across a significant sample of respondents in a clear, structured manner.
CHAPTER FOUR
DATA PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION
Data Presentation
Demographic Distribution of Respondents
The data in Table 4.1 shows the distribution of responses to a questionnaire administered to a sample of 120 participants. Out of the total distributed questionnaires, 109 were completed and returned, while 11 were either not returned or left uncompleted. This resulted in a high response rate of 90.8%, indicating strong engagement from the participants. The unreturned or incomplete questionnaires accounted for only 9.2% of the total sample.
A response rate of over 90% is generally considered very favorable, as it suggests a high level of interest or commitment from the participants, minimizing the likelihood of non-response bias. This high completion rate adds reliability to the study findings, as a more complete dataset can provide a clearer understanding of the population’s views and reduce the potential for skewed results that may arise from lower response rates. Consequently, the results are likely to be a robust representation of the intended study group.
The cumulative percentages in the table highlight that the valid response data captures the views of nearly the entire sample (90.8%), with all data represented in the total percentage reaching 100%. This cumulative perspective confirms that the study reached the majority of its target audience, which enhances the generalizability of the study findings. Given that only a small portion of responses was missing, the impact of non-responses on the overall analysis should be minimal, allowing for a more comprehensive and accurate assessment of the research questions.
CHAPTER FIVE
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Summary of Findings
The study aimed to assess the impact of organizational change, digital transformation, restructuring initiatives, and employee adaptability on the performance of commercial banks in Delta and Rivers States. The findings revealed significant relationships between these factors and key performance indicators, including operational efficiency, customer satisfaction, financial performance, and the success of organizational changes.
The first key finding of the study was that organizational change had a significant positive effect on the operational efficiency of commercial banks. The results indicated that the implementation of organizational changes, such as process streamlining, system upgrades, and departmental restructuring, played a crucial role in improving the efficiency of banking operations. Banks that embraced change were able to optimize their processes, improve resource allocation, and enhance service delivery, leading to more effective operations overall.
The second important finding was that digital transformation had a considerable impact on customer satisfaction. The study showed that the adoption of digital banking technologies, such as mobile banking, online platforms, and automated systems, significantly improved the banking experience for customers in Delta and Rivers States. The results highlighted that customers appreciated the convenience, accessibility, and speed offered by digital banking services, which ultimately led to higher levels of satisfaction.
Restructuring initiatives in commercial banks were found to have a positive effect on financial performance. The study revealed that restructuring efforts, which included changes in management practices, organizational structures, and business strategies, contributed to the banks’ improved profitability and financial resilience. The banks that successfully implemented restructuring were better equipped to navigate challenges, optimize resource usage, and respond to market demands, resulting in stronger financial outcomes.
Conclusion
The study concluded that organizational change significantly enhances operational efficiency in commercial banks within Delta and Rivers States. This finding underscores the need for structured and well-implemented change management processes to improve bank operations and competitiveness. The positive impact of digital transformation on customer satisfaction highlights the critical role of technology in delivering efficient and customer-centered services, emphasizing the importance of continuous investment in digital platforms to meet evolving customer expectations.
Restructuring initiatives were found to have a significant positive effect on the financial performance of commercial banks. This suggests that organizational reforms, when carefully executed, contribute to financial stability and profitability. The findings further revealed that employee adaptability plays a pivotal role in the success of organizational change, demonstrating that an adaptable workforce is essential for implementing new systems and processes effectively.
Recommendations
Based on the findings, the following recommendations can be made to commercial banks in Delta and Rivers States:
- Prioritize Effective Organizational Change ManagementGiven the positive impact of organizational change on operational efficiency, banks should develop and implement structured change management strategies. This includes clearly communicating the need for change, involving employees at all levels, and providing the necessary resources and training to ensure smooth transitions. Implementing change management frameworks like Kotter’s 8-Step Change Model can help banks manage restructuring processes more effectively, leading to improved operational outcomes.
- Invest in Digital Transformation to Enhance Customer SatisfactionThe research highlights the significant role of digital transformation in improving customer satisfaction. Therefore, banks should invest in upgrading their digital infrastructure, including mobile apps, online banking systems, and automation tools, to provide a more convenient and efficient banking experience for customers. Additionally, focusing on user-friendly interfaces, security features, and personalized services through digital platforms will help in retaining customers and building loyalty.
- Focus on Restructuring Initiatives to Improve Financial PerformanceThe study shows that restructuring initiatives have a positive impact on the financial performance of commercial banks. Banks should regularly assess their organizational structure and identify areas for improvement, such as resource allocation, cost management, and workflow optimization. Implementing continuous restructuring initiatives that focus on streamlining operations and reducing inefficiencies can enhance profitability and long-term financial stability.
Further studies could explore the long-term effects of digital transformation on customer loyalty and retention in commercial banks. While this study focused on the immediate impact of digital platforms on customer satisfaction, future research could investigate how these transformations influence customer behavior over an extended period. Researchers could analyze factors such as repeat business, customer referrals, and engagement levels with digital banking services to understand the broader implications of digital adoption on customer loyalty. Additionally, examining how different demographic groups (age, income, location) respond to digital banking initiatives could provide a more nuanced understanding of the customer experience.
Another area for future research is the impact of employee adaptability on the overall organizational culture in the banking sector. This study highlighted the importance of adaptability for successful organizational change, but further research could delve into how this adaptability contributes to building a resilient and positive work culture. Future studies could focus on the relationship between employee adaptability, job satisfaction, and overall productivity, exploring how fostering a culture of continuous learning and flexibility can improve not only the success of organizational changes but also the broader work environment in banks. This would provide valuable insights into how to create a workforce that is not only adaptable but also motivated and engaged in the change process.
References
- Ajani, A. O., Abdulraheem, I., Olufayo, T. O., & Aremu, I. L. (2022). Management of change practices as a catalyst to employee’s performance among licensed fast foods in Lagos State, Nigeria. Journal of Management Sciences, 58(1), 121-129.
- Ajani, A. O. (2021). Effect of change management practices on employee’s attitude among selected eateries in Lagos State, Nigeria. ProQuest Dissertations and Theses (PQDT) Global database.
- Al-Omari, K., & Okasheh, H. (2017). The effect of work environment on job performance: A case study of engineering company in Jordan. International Journal of Applied Engineering Research, 12, 15544-15550.
- Armstrong, M. (2021). Strategic human resource management: A handbook of human resource management practice (10th ed.). London: Kogan Page.
- Asogbua, S. N., Obi, I. O., & Ezejiofor, R. A. (2022). Work environment and employee performance of commercial banks in Nigeria. Journal of Global Interdependence and Economic Sustainability, 1(1), 1-15.
